Teach for America

Eclipsing Paid Media Goals by 124%

Content Strategy, Distribution Strategy

Executive Summary: Teach for America fell short of teacher recruitment goals for seven straight years and needed to uplevel their paid media strategy to get quality candidates into classrooms and advance educational equity. We crafted a test-led paid media approach optimized for learning and iteration across a $1.2 million spend, actively shifting budget to best-performing channels monthly. By listening to interview teams and adjusting for candidate quality beyond just click-throughs, we eclipsed paid media goals by 124% while ensuring no budget was wasted and every effort delivered measurable ROI.

The Mission: Get teachers into classrooms.

Teach for America is an organization on the frontlines of achieving educational equity. Recruiting capable teachers is a huge part of the organization’s success, but after falling short of their recruitment goals for seven years, they were eager to uplevel their paid media outreach strategy. TFA specifically tapped us for our ability to reach niche audiences in media targeting. With the opportunity to contribute to educational equity on the table, we instantly connected with the TFA team and their unique challenge.

A test-led approach helped us identify ROI and lean into what worked.

After reviewing previous campaign results, audience analysis based on past performance, media vendor information, and TFA historical application data, we crafted a paid media strategy optimized for learning and iteration. Through this flexible system, we could effectively test, improve, and increase the efficacy of every campaign to maximize the results of the complete $1.2 million spend.

By actively and responsibly shifting budget to our best-performing media channels/tactics each month, we ensured no budget was wasted, the team gained valuable insights to inform future campaigns, and every effort delivered notable ROI.

We found quality candidates across a number of channels.

Our campaigns reached across a spread of channels, including job postings on AppCast, Indeed, and LinkedIn, as well as search marketing, TikTok, Facebook, and Instagram. We also delivered creative across programmatic digital ad networks.

Click-throughs weren’t the only market feedback for us to heed—this was, after all, a lead-generation effort. Candidates who apply face a tough vetting process, so we listened to the interview teams and adjusted to improve candidate quality across campaigns.

FAQ

Column Five’s work for Teach for America is an example of a paid media strategy for teacher recruitment. After the organization fell short of its recruitment goals for seven straight years, Column Five ran a test-led program across a $1.2 million spend and shifted budget to the best-performing channels each month. The campaigns eclipsed Teach for America’s paid media goals by 124%.

Column Five helped Teach for America eclipse its paid media goals with a strategy built for testing and iteration. The plan drew on previous campaign results, audience analysis based on past performance, media vendor information, and the organization’s historical application data. Column Five then moved budget toward the channels and tactics that performed best, so no budget was wasted and the team gained insights for future campaigns.

A paid media recruitment campaign like Teach for America’s includes job boards, search, social media, and programmatic advertising. Ours reached candidates through:

  • Job postings on AppCast, Indeed, and LinkedIn
  • Search marketing
  • Social campaigns on TikTok, Facebook, and Instagram
  • Creative across programmatic digital ad networks

A test-led paid media strategy is a plan that treats campaigns as ongoing experiments and moves budget toward the channels and tactics that perform best. For Teach for America, we judged results on candidate quality as well as click-throughs, because applicants face a tough vetting process. We listened to the interview teams and adjusted campaigns to bring in stronger candidates.

Show me more work

Samsung + Android Enterprise playbook and whitepaper for JPMorgan Chase, part of an AI-powered ABM content program for 57 financial services accounts

Samsung + Android Enterprise

AI-Powered ABM Content for 57 Financial Services Accounts

VideoAmp SaaS webinar engine landing page and social media assets designed by Column Five

VideoAmp

5X the Webinar Engagement in 90 Days

Ask a Marketing Expert

C5's GPT offers expert advice and resources to solve your marketing problems. Ask a question, or start with these prompts.

Build a competitive content strategy
Create content at scale
Implement AI marketing
Bridge sales and marketing
Improve marketing ROI
Build a strong brand strategy